Questions about motors
Forums:
Hello,
I have a couple of questions about the diddy Borg motors and others
1) What would be a speed comparison between diddyborg red motors and generic 50:1 micro metal gear motors
2) How do diddy Borg red motors and monsterborg motors compare in terms of speed
3) Are monster Borg motors available separately
4) If I was to use a zero Borg to drive 6 motors would it be best to have all 3 motors on each side connected or just 2 with 1 connected driven separately on a separate channel.
5) would there be any speed disparity with the second way
I hope this would be the right place to post as it is mainly about diddyborg mototrs!
Thank you in advance for the help.
piborg
Sat, 08/05/2017 - 22:38
Permalink
Motor advice
Motors can be a bit of a confusing topic, hopefully the answers below will make things clearer.
1. The actual speed of both motors will depend somewhat on the robot they are used in. You can think of motors as having two kinds of power associated to them:
In this case I would expect the 50:1 micro metal gear motors to turn about 5-6x faster than the DiddyBorg Red Edition motors when they are spinning on their own. However they have a massively lower torque value, meaning they do not like moving much weight.
In practice with a small, light robot the micro motors will probably be noticeably quicker. With a robot of a similar size and weight to DiddyBorg they will probably move somewhat slower than the Red Edition motors, and will probably struggle to turn on the spot (tank-steer) on most surfaces.
In short for small robots the micro motors will be faster, but on medium sized or larger robots the Red Edition motors will generally end up being faster.
2. MonsterBorg motors are both faster and have a stronger turning force than the DiddyBorg Red Edition motors. They are about 3x the speed of Red Edition motors. The down side is they are much larger and use a bit more power.
3. At the moment no, we may make them available for purchase sometime in the future though.
4. This is a bit tricky to answer, it will largely depend on what motors you are using:
Technically two motors on a single ZeroBorg output is outside of the current limit for the ZeroBorg in the worst case, but you might get away with it. Connecting three to the same output would be a bad idea as you would almost certainly try and draw too much power through the board on sharp changes of speed!
ZeroBorg will happily drive a single one of these per output, but it will definitely not tolerate two per output. In short you could use four Red Edition motors (one per output) at most with a ZeroBorg.
ZeroBorg is not up to the task of driving these at all, they are far too powerful for the board! They require a more powerful board such as our ThunderBorg.
In all three cases you would probably be better off with our ThunderBorg controller for a six motor robot. This will cope with all three motors per side for the micro or Red Edition motors. From memory it is only really capable of two MonsterBorg motors per output though.
5. In short yes, there would be a difference between the single motor and the pair. Under most circumstances they will be similar enough to be ignored, but there are exceptions:
in most cases though you would be hard pressed to notice the difference. What I would suggest is that if you do go for a pair and a single on the same side use the singles for the central wheels on each side as they do most of the work in a six wheel robot when turning on the spot.
William Worthy
Sun, 08/06/2017 - 08:02
Permalink
Great thanks a tonne for the
Great thanks a tonne for the great response I think a thunderbird and six diddyborg red motors is the way to go!
William Worthy
Sun, 08/06/2017 - 08:13
Permalink
Thunderborg motors
Is thunderborg the same in terms of powering? As in it powers the pi and motors from a 9v battery or is pi powered separately?
piborg
Sun, 08/06/2017 - 09:22
Permalink
ThunderBorg power
The ThunderBorg does power the Raspberry Pi from the same battery as the motors use.
As for power a 9V battery would work, but you would not get the full speed from the motors. The Red Edition motors run at full speed with 12V so you will want a battery pack which is at least 12V to get them up to full power. We usually use a 10x AA battery pack with rechargeable AAs (rated at 1.2V) which works out as 12V :)